A few years back, my mom and I went through a period of frustration with our chocolate chip cookie recipe. We were probably like most people in the fact that we just always used the recipe off the bag of chocolate chips. While the cookies were always tasty, we were disappointed when the cookies seemed kind of flat, or would even fall apart when scooping them off the cookie sheet. Enough was enough, and my mom sought out to find a better recipe. What she found was a beautiful, ingenious recipe that makes THE BEST cookies. She discovered the recipe on allrecipes.com, and while there are similar ones still on the site, I have not been able to find this exact recipe the past few times I've looked.
If you're one who prefers their cookies crispy, this recipe isn't for you, but for us normal people who like to indulge in a super soft cookie every now and again, you have got to try this recipe! I make these cookies quite often, and some tough critics have given them two thumbs up (they've too busy eating the cookies to actually say much of anything). On this particular occasion, I made a batch to bring with me when I went to visit my boyfriend (upon his request) and then snuck a few back to give to a some of my new friends at work. Everyone seemed to really enjoy them and that always makes my day.
Chocolate Chip Cookies
4 & 1/2 C Flour 2 tsp. Baking Soda
1/2 C Sugar 1 & 1/2 C Brown Sugar
2 C Salted Butter 2 packages Instant Vanilla Pudding Mix
4 Eggs 2 tsp. Vanilla
4 C Chocolate Chips
Combine dry ingredients and set aside. Cream together butter and sugars. Beat in instant pudding mix. Stir in eggs and vanilla. Blend in flour mixture. Stir in chocolate chips. Scoop onto greased cookie sheet and bake at 350 degrees F for 10-12 minutes.
I was so excited to have my first baking "assignment", as I got to finally use my new mixer that was a graduation present from my parents!
(Helpful Hint: The temperature of your butter is no joking matter. It needs to be soft enough to leave slight indentions when pressed on, but not overly soft as this will make your cookies less fluffy.)
Another great thing about this recipe is its versatility! As you can see by this picture, I actually added a bag of milk chocolate chips and a bag of peanut butter chips upon request. Although I have not tried anything else, I am convinced this batter could handle about anything you put in it! CAUTION: This batter gets thick, so be sure to have a sturdy spatula ready for stirring!
(Helpful Hint: Along with the temperature of the butter, the temperature of the batter is also very important in making this cookies turn out to the right consistency. This batter does well if made in advance and refrigerated, but allow plenty of time for it to come to room temperature...but don't allow it to get too soft either.)
This recipe makes A TON of cookies. I'm talking like 5 dozen. Great for a crowd, or to freeze and pull out as needed (p.s. these cookies are GREAT frozen and would make perfect ice cream sandwiches). I have halved the recipe before, but for some reason I feel that the full recipe makes them taste better. While that may not logically make sense, I'm sticking to it.
ENJOY!